Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xocetaceans

(3,994 posts)
4. So, is this guy another hack reporter pushing the "flat-earth" virology of the lab leak hypothesis at 4:47 in the video?
Sun Jan 5, 2025, 01:15 PM
Sunday

Should his reporting even be taken seriously? Has he even bothered to check on what data is out there? talked with actual virologists?

How about the following suggestion: maybe...Martians planted the virus as revenge for the plot of War of the Worlds too? Some people just wrote that statement after all, so maybe he should report that with a deadpan affect and an air of seriousness. Also, some people think the Earth is flat.

His reporting might better belong in a hybrid group forum of foreign affairs and science fiction or MAGA conspiracy theories since his other source for his lab leak hypothesis is a (GOP/MAGA-led) US government report. Which congressional MAGA nutjobs are behind that? Johnson? Jordan? Massie? Keep in mind that that group is likely going to fall in behind RFK, Jr. and probably chase down every vaccine-related rabbit hole he might consider to be "profitably" exploitable. What is Kennedy after all other than merely a health grifter at this point? He has no knowledge of virology, yet unabashedly is anti-vax. His book on Fauci is a demonstrable piece of trash.

Anyway, this reporter's "credibility" might...ought to be reconsidered given his willingness to parrot such a claims that the lab leak hypothesis is "plausible" and is "the likely explanation".

Find the data, report on the data, and if there is no time of staff for that, maybe stories just to fill time should not be produced.

How many people died as a result of stupid takes on virology caused by rabbit-hole reporting? Far too many.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

We are on the uptake with respiratory and flu here also. Historic NY Sunday #1
I like his measured take GreatGazoo Sunday #2
Human Metapneumovirus (HMPV) is not new. It circulates in the US and elsewhere in winter at same time as RSV, FLU hlthe2b Sunday #3
So, is this guy another hack reporter pushing the "flat-earth" virology of the lab leak hypothesis at 4:47 in the video? xocetaceans Sunday #4
Tony is not a hack reporter. TexasTowelie Sunday #6
Check the data on your "engineered virus" statement. You don't really know that any better than he does. n/t xocetaceans Monday #7
Really? TexasTowelie Monday #8
My statement is not one of "either...or". My point is you have no data of "yours" it came from a lab. xocetaceans Monday #9
Thanks for providing a link, but I'm not going to watch a 55 minute video from a virology class lecture. TexasTowelie Yesterday #10
Reading your comment again, I wanted to add one other thing. TexasTowelie Yesterday #11
I can only guess your background absent such extending comments. There is no intent to demean it. This is not a... xocetaceans Yesterday #12
You are correct that I fused HMPV and RSV together--it looked odd when I was typing it but I didn't check my work. TexasTowelie 21 hrs ago #13
I appreciate your comments. I think that I was fairly sharp-edged in a comment/reply to one of your posts a few years... xocetaceans 14 hrs ago #14
I like this guy Easterncedar Sunday #5
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Foreign Affairs»China's New Virus Outbrea...»Reply #4