A piddly question, a "why do they do that?" regarding music education... [View all]
My background: I was a band member in school beginning in 6th grade through college. Sixth graders rehearsed together. 7 & 8th graders rehearsed with high school band because it was a small school, but also performed as 7 & 8th graders at middle school events. Rehearsing and performing with high schoolers raised my ability level significantly. The older kids helped the younger ones.
The question: Why do middle schools have separate Concert and Symphonic bands? Why do 12 & 13 year olds need to compete for placement at this age? Why can't older/better musicians assist younger ones? I can understand having a Beginning band for beginners, but does separating 7 & 8 graders into two different bands (not based on grade level) make a big difference in growth in musicianship?
= new reply since forum marked as read