Latest Breaking News

moniss

(6,408 posts)

10. He didn't die from being taken. You die

Reply to MarineCombatEngineer (Reply #9)

Fri Jan 10, 2025, 06:29 PM

Jan 10

from an inflicted injury or illness/natural causes. That is what kills human beings. I'm approaching the question the way a coroner would. As far as responsibility for deaths goes the IDF and the radical right Israeli government bear responsibility for prisoner deaths and any deaths in Gaza or the West Bank due to lack of medical care/supplies, food, water and shelter. All of those items are requirements by international law for forces to provide civilians. Unless of course you accept the radical right parties in Israel saying there is no such thing as a civilian or innocent Palestinian. I get the strong sense that they use that to justify an "anything goes" approach. I really don't think you mean that.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

endgenocide

24 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Israel identifies body of hostage recovered from Gaza, days after father's remains were found [View all] sarisataka Jan 10 OP

Peace be upon him... hlthe2b Jan 10 #1

"Bedouin Muslims kidnapped and murdered by Hamas" Lulu KC Jan 10 #2

May the perpetrators of this horror... Richard D Jan 10 #3

I agree endgenocide Jan 10 #4

Just couldn't resist throwing this in could you? MarineCombatEngineer Jan 10 #5

Do think the innocent endgenocide Jan 10 #11

That isn't what this thread is about, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 10 #14

A reason why some join. And then disappear question everything Jan 11 #20

Haters gonna hate . . . Richard D Jan 10 #12

I wonder how long it will take for someone to blame Israel for this hostage's death? MarineCombatEngineer Jan 10 #6

Cause of death isn't stated. Was he blown up in the tunnel moniss Jan 10 #8

The cause of death was HAMAs taking him hostage, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 10 #9

He didn't die from being taken. You die moniss Jan 10 #10

He died because he was viciously kidnapped by the terrorist org., HAMAs, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 10 #13

You miss the point entirely. nt moniss Jan 10 #15

No kidnapping, no death. That's the point AZLD4Candidate Jan 10 #16

If a husband shoots his wife you don't put moniss Jan 11 #17

I revel in the death of no one. I just don't make excuses for it. AZLD4Candidate Jan 11 #18

I have no idea why someone asking a different question is such moniss Jan 11 #19

my opinion? i lived there for three years. I have friends there. AZLD4Candidate Jan 11 #21

I could care less where you've been you have no call coming at moniss Jan 11 #22

No, i'm not, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 11 #23

Once again you're wrong and missing the point. moniss Jan 11 #24

Yeah, Hamas doesn't give a shit who they Kill as Cha Jan 10 #7