Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DFW

(56,966 posts)
44. You had an easier time than I did Well done!
Tue Oct 26, 2021, 01:42 PM
Oct 2021

My dad’s mom collected modern art in the 1940s and 1950s. Living artists with names like Alberto Giacometti.

When she passed away in 1966, all the grandkids could pick one painting or sculpture. My cousin wanted a Giacometti bronze, but it was assessed at $16000. My aunt and uncle couldn’t afford the (then-) applicable 50% inheritance tax of $8000. The sculpture came up for sale some 40 years later, and brought $4 million.

I was always fond of an abstract blue painting by an artist who died AFTER my grandmother did, and so my parents only had to pay $300, i.e. half of the assessed $600.

Well, fast forward, and the artist who did my painting now has his own room at the MoMa. BUT—since my grandmother bought her painting directly from the artist, the NY art snobs said my painting had to be a fake. They kept that up for years until I finally found a photo of the artist sitting in a Paris gallery (the one that issued my grandmother the bill of sale), with him and the gallery owner sitting under MY PAINTING!

Long story short, I decided I had had enough of the painting, and sold it. As an inheritance kept for more than one year after acquisition, I owed the Germans nothing (THERE was a first!). But the IRS came and said I owed 31.8% on the gain—be prepared, by the way, you might be in a similar position. Consult a tax attorney! You might not like the news, but it’s better than being called in for tax evasion down the road. Besides, what’s left over will be one hell of a sum, too.

So, I paid the IRS their 31.8%, and then gave my brother and sister and each of their spouses $50,000 each, spreading it out to be under the yearly limit for gift tax. Nothing they inherited was worth six figures, and the last thing I was gonna do was flash my good fortune in their faces.

Ergo, I ended up with a sum that was less than half what the painting sold for, but I got something even more valuable: a great relationship with my siblings for life, plus some insurance that I could pay all my daughters’ education bills in the States.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Congrats! SheltieLover Oct 2021 #1
OMG MARK! FalloutShelter Oct 2021 #2
Details please - what painting? ramblin_dave Oct 2021 #3
Here's the original post bif Oct 2021 #5
Wonderful outcome! IrishAfricanAmerican Oct 2021 #4
Congratulations! LoisB Oct 2021 #6
How does your wife like it now?! babylonsister Oct 2021 #7
Awesome!!! nt Phoenix61 Oct 2021 #8
This message was self-deleted by its author Chin music Oct 2021 #9
if it is this one drray23 Oct 2021 #10
Or possibly this one of Amsterdam PatSeg Oct 2021 #25
Definitely is that one, judging by the details. I'm thrilled that it sold for so much. highplainsdem Oct 2021 #38
I love this paragragh, given what you've said about its life in your home. RobertDevereaux Oct 2021 #40
OMG Congratulations! bucolic_frolic Oct 2021 #11
Congratulations!!! CaptainTruth Oct 2021 #12
OMG!!! Congratulations!!! Lisa0825 Oct 2021 #13
Fantastic! lillypaddle Oct 2021 #14
Congrats! irisblue Oct 2021 #15
Hey old pal, I need a brake job on my truck. panader0 Oct 2021 #16
Your brakes can wait. Cracklin Charlie Oct 2021 #19
Wow! Sold for over 2 to 3 times the estimate! How does it feel to be in the upper class? Congrats. sinkingfeeling Oct 2021 #17
Hot damn! that's great! :) nt Javaman Oct 2021 #18
Congratulations! Cracklin Charlie Oct 2021 #20
Wow, you owned the Picasso that sold for 110M..damn you're rich! Just kidding RestoreAmerica2020 Oct 2021 #21
Boy with a pipe? robbob Oct 2021 #27
What a wonderful surprise! brer cat Oct 2021 #22
What an extraordinary story! PatSeg Oct 2021 #23
That's awesome, hope the buyer enjoys it or loans to museum n/t hibbing Oct 2021 #24
I'm so-o-o-o-o happy for you !!! fierywoman Oct 2021 #26
Yeah!!!!!!! Hurray!!!!! How exciting MLAA Oct 2021 #28
That's incredible! cate94 Oct 2021 #29
Almost a million British Pounds! edhopper Oct 2021 #30
It's a great painting. I'd love to have it. Congrats. Auggie Oct 2021 #31
🥂 blm Oct 2021 #32
I'm just shaking my head in disbelief! bif Oct 2021 #33
You've got a great eye. Congratulations! yonder Oct 2021 #37
Well done! UpInArms Oct 2021 #43
Are you looking at a hefty tax bill? OneCrazyDiamond Oct 2021 #60
Congratulations! gademocrat7 Oct 2021 #34
that's great! barbtries Oct 2021 #35
So happy for you wryter2000 Oct 2021 #36
"... was spotted and bought by a discerning local collector and aesthete" Congrats! MomInTheCrowd Oct 2021 #39
Oh that's wonderful! Congratulations! Money is always nice, especially an unexpected bonus! LiberalLoner Oct 2021 #41
Did anyone ever tell you that you have a long lost brother who loves you very much? Beastly Boy Oct 2021 #42
You had an easier time than I did Well done! DFW Oct 2021 #44
Great story! bif Oct 2021 #45
you are worth it! Skittles Oct 2021 #46
Wow, what a fantastic ending to a great story! Enjoy! 🎉🎉🎉 electric_blue68 Oct 2021 #47
Wow! That's great!! lunatica Oct 2021 #48
Ha! I wish! Here's the original posting about the painting... bif Oct 2021 #50
Thanks for the link - I remember it now. lunatica Oct 2021 #66
This is awesome! Yorkie Mom Oct 2021 #49
How wonderful malaise Oct 2021 #51
Hey artist, you got a dollar? tavernier Oct 2021 #52
Congratulations! femmedem Oct 2021 #53
I hope you're not so rich that you become a Republican and leave us. Midnight Writer Oct 2021 #54
Who knew DU has..... SergeStorms Oct 2021 #55
Well, I pitted Christie's against Sotheby's and got an amazing deal bif Oct 2021 #56
What was Sotheby's buyer's fee.... SergeStorms Oct 2021 #57
I honestly don't know bif Oct 2021 #64
Congratulations.. Historic NY Oct 2021 #58
Amazing experience, I bet. Congratulations! ancianita Oct 2021 #59
WOW! How freaking awesome is that? lark Oct 2021 #61
Wow! Congratulations to you on the sale! MontanaMama Oct 2021 #62
Congrats! Tom Yossarian Joad Oct 2021 #63
What an astonishing and delightful story. 3catwoman3 Oct 2021 #65
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Artists»Sotheby's just sold my pa...»Reply #44