Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AZLD4Candidate

(6,411 posts)
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:10 AM Nov 28

Top Ten worst animated child characters of all time.

This will be something I do or will try to do every week. A top ten list of things in pop culture. The list is subjective to my opinion, but feedback and entries you list could be used in future lists as long as the feedback is relatively polite. Now, on with the list.

Cartoons are fun. Cartoons can be enjoyable. But there are characters that drag a good cartoon down with their mere presence and grind the show to a halt until they disappear. This list looks at child characters that I believe ruin shows, so Family Guy’s Herb the Perv will not be on the list (that joke lasted about three seconds).

To make the list, there are some rules.
1: It must a series, so no “one time specials” like Frosty and Rudolph or Dr. Seuss specials do not qualify.
2: If the character appears in shorts, they must be more than a one time character.
3: The character MUST be a child. Pepe Le Pew is pathetic, but he is an adult character.

Here are the top ten with an honorable mention:

HM: Dee Dee - Dexter’s Laboratory. While a good foil for Dexter, she was beyond annoying and watching Dexter run around trying to fix or clean up the things Dee Dee broke or destroyed became tiresome and boring after three or for episodes. No one can be THAT stupid.

10: Hadji Singh - Jonny Quest. To be perfectly honest, I HATED the Jonny Quest series, from its original well animated version, to its cheap turn to childhood hijinx, to its 1990s revival on cartoon network. But Hadji was the worst. The stereotype of Indian children with mysterious powers of “Singh-Singh, Salah Bing.” Ugh. If he were Chinese, he would be able to fly and run on walls, something I’ve asked my wife for years to show me how to do since she’s Chinese. See, stereotypes suck.

9: Charles and Mambo - Duckman. Duckman is a really under-rated USA Network cartoon. I loved every minute of it until either Aunt Bernice or Charles and Mamdo spoke. Two (well, three since Charles and Mambo are conjoint twins) unlikable terrible characters that look down on everyone, think they are perfect, and should get their asses kicked each time they speak.

8: Lisa Simpson - The Simpsons. I LOVE The Simpsons. I’m glad in season four the changed the focus from Bart to Homer and made him twice as stupid. It solidified the longevity of the show as you can do more with Homer than you can with Bart. But Lisa has always driven me nuts. Haughty, aloof, with a Goddess complex, maven characters that take themselves too serious are a drag. Marge would be on this list too but this is child characters only.

7: Eugene Belcher - Bob’s Burgers. Don’t get me wrong, I love Eugene. But he’s nothing more than an older version of Ralph Wiggum with a more annoying voice that couldn’t zip up his fly without ripping his pants. His non-sequitir dialogue is amusing in doses, but when he’s given too many lines, the show become tedious. Bob and Louise should be the focus on most episodes. Eugene heavy episodes are a slog.

6: Nermal - Garfield and Friends. Good God do I loathe the world’s cutest kitten. While Garfield is highly unlikeable, this character is there just to make Garfield feel like he’s crap on a cracker. The character serves absolutely no purpose and adds nothing to an otherwise inane and humorless cartoon.

5: Shelley Marsh - South Park. Talk about a girl destined for prison. She hates everyone. She abuses her younger brother. She insults her parents. She beats up anyone she wants and she never gets in trouble or faces punishment. Quiet frankly, this character is awful and the less we see of her the better. Cartman may be a prick but he’s used like Gary Trudeau uses Duke. Shelley has no purpose except cruelty.

4: Huey, Dewey, and Louie - Disney shorts and Quack Pack. As children in the shorts, they were obnoxious disobedient, violent, disrespectful, and just plan sociopathic. They would make Donald angry or take Donald’s prank too far, then turn is life upside down, win, and show children at the time it’s okay to be a prick to people who take care of you. Every time Donald got even with them, I cheered.

3: Godzuki - Godzilla animated series. More Hanna Barbera bullshit. The animated series shat all over the campy Japanese monster, but to give Godzilla an bumbling, useless offspring was just one of the worst decisions ever. Godzuki was an animated Gilligan where the humor in the hijinx was muted by the fact that show was GOD AWFUL. Also Godzuki could fly. WTF???

2: Scrappy Doo - Scooby Doo. Scrappy Doo added nothing to the formula. It was fine without him. Then the executives though a child character would bring something younger (what, three years old?) viewers could relate more to than five hippies and their great dane. Scrappy is one of the worst characters ever on many lists and he is #2 on here. As awful as he is, the hands down #1 worst child character is:

1: Lucy Van Pelt - Peanuts. Good grief, what can I say about this harpie of a character. She’s cruel, manipulative, insulting, aloof, violent, dismissive, aggressive, rude, self-centered, and treats everyone, especially her younger brother Linus and Charlie Brown (a character I relate to perfectly) especially terrible, working to effectively ruin whatever self worth and self-esteem Charlie Brown could try to develop. At least, in Family Guy, Peter Griffin finally gave Lucy what she all but deserved by kicking her ass for not letting Charlie Brown kick the football. There is absolutely nothing likable about Lucy Van Pelt, so she goes down as the worst animated child character in TV history.

22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Top Ten worst animated child characters of all time. (Original Post) AZLD4Candidate Nov 28 OP
You can make it simple--almost ALL of them since the 70s. hlthe2b Nov 28 #1
As an adult... all I have to say about Lucy from Peanuts is... lapfog_1 Nov 28 #2
now that I think about it, she was spot on MY older sister FirstLight Nov 28 #9
A large percentage of cartoonists are male FakeNoose Nov 28 #3
I included male cartoon characters too. Eugene Belcher. Scrappy Doo. AZLD4Candidate Nov 28 #5
Yes, and Lisa Hope22 Nov 28 #7
If that's all you got out of my post, I feel bad for you. I mentioned twice as many male characters AZLD4Candidate Nov 28 #16
Don't feel bad for me watching you........you doubled down. Nice Hope22 Nov 28 #17
I think her point was one of the girl child character's you slamned Is considered to be electric_blue68 Nov 28 #18
No, but as a writer, smug characters tend to bother me and I knew Lisa would be a contraversial selection AZLD4Candidate Nov 29 #19
Well, these are rather embeded pop characters currently in our culture so they imho mean something. electric_blue68 Dec 5 #22
I got a kick out of this! Ocelot II Nov 28 #4
Nermal was the character I chose and Nermal is a kitten. AZLD4Candidate Nov 28 #14
OK, I guess a kitten counts as a child. Ocelot II Nov 28 #15
lucy van pelt. period . scrappy do. ugh. AllaN01Bear Nov 28 #6
Never gave it much thought, and don't think I will. Sneederbunk Nov 28 #8
Any animated character that is near-terminally stupid. Archae Nov 28 #10
Great list! Polybius Nov 28 #11
I made it. Share all you want. I will post one a week. AZLD4Candidate Nov 28 #13
Captain Caveman Trellastic Nov 28 #12
Hey, who you callin' a dumb broad? Lulu KC Nov 29 #20
Except for Richie Rich, none are child cartoon characters. Jerry will be another list I will make, trust me. AZLD4Candidate Dec 4 #21

hlthe2b

(107,059 posts)
1. You can make it simple--almost ALL of them since the 70s.
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:14 AM
Nov 28

Uggh.

But, I give a pass to Lucy. She's the perfect "foil" for Charlie Brown, Snoopy, and Linus.

FirstLight

(14,350 posts)
9. now that I think about it, she was spot on MY older sister
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 12:47 PM
Nov 28

and that bitch hasn't changed a bit (probably voted for TFG too)

FakeNoose

(36,130 posts)
3. A large percentage of cartoonists are male
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:24 AM
Nov 28

... so your gripes are mainly directed at the male cartoonists, not with the characters they created.

They've created fictional characters to illustrate their gripes against women, or at least some women.

AZLD4Candidate

(6,411 posts)
5. I included male cartoon characters too. Eugene Belcher. Scrappy Doo.
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:47 AM
Nov 28

Let's leave politics out of this please.

Out of the eleven I picked, only four were female.

Hope22

(3,196 posts)
7. Yes, and Lisa
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:57 AM
Nov 28

Smart, talented and not afraid to speak her mind……we can’t have that. This country is way further down the rabbit hole than any man can imagine or might admit!

AZLD4Candidate

(6,411 posts)
16. If that's all you got out of my post, I feel bad for you. I mentioned twice as many male characters
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 02:56 PM
Nov 28

electric_blue68

(19,049 posts)
18. I think her point was one of the girl child character's you slamned Is considered to be
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 09:51 PM
Nov 28
"Smart, talented and not afraid to speak her mind"


With and I say maybe since I don't know for sure Lisa speaking her mind a problem for you?

AZLD4Candidate

(6,411 posts)
19. No, but as a writer, smug characters tend to bother me and I knew Lisa would be a contraversial selection
Fri Nov 29, 2024, 07:58 AM
Nov 29

Again, we're arguing over fictional characters. WTF?

electric_blue68

(19,049 posts)
22. Well, these are rather embeded pop characters currently in our culture so they imho mean something.
Thu Dec 5, 2024, 11:50 PM
Dec 5

I certainly didn't think of Lisa as smug.
Maaaybe pithy. And I liked it.

Ocelot II

(121,774 posts)
4. I got a kick out of this!
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 11:31 AM
Nov 28

Is Garfield technically a child, or do childlike animals count? Agree about the Garfield strip. Garfield is kind of a dick, but how much mileage can you get out of a cartoon cat who's obsessed with food? Real cats are obsessed with food. The problem with cartoon animals is that eventually they become too human, and then the humor about their animal characteristics is lost. Garfield was funnier when he was more like a cat. Nermal is just a prop. So are the humans.

Lucy works as a character because she provides a contrast to the other characters. Charlie Brown is sort of downtrodden; I could always relate to him when I was a kid (hoping for a valentine that never came) and Lucy regularly picks on him with her football trick. You'd think he'd learn, but hope springs eternal. Maybe that's the lesson, but I've always kind of wanted Charlie Brown to kick her butt. I sort of like it that a kids' comic strip has a villain, though.

Archae

(46,920 posts)
10. Any animated character that is near-terminally stupid.
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 01:23 PM
Nov 28

Like "Bonehead" from "Dinosaucers" or Fred Flintstone.

Trellastic

(60 posts)
12. Captain Caveman
Thu Nov 28, 2024, 01:50 PM
Nov 28

Whoops- just noticed the characters are supposed to be children, some on list are.

1. Captain Caveman and the three angels. His nose looks like a dong and his sidekicks are dumb bimbos.

2. Olive Oyl- a dumb broad who constantly needs to be rescued.

3. Caillou's parents- calm to a weird degree.

4. Fred Flintstone- always yelling 'Wilma', Wilma Flintstone for enabling Fred to be such an entitled doofus.

5. Angelica's parents on Rug Rats for terrible parenting and raising a future narcissist.

6. The Shmoo- dumb phallic character

7. Strawberry Shortcake-Mind numbing cartoon without substance. A big glob of pink artificially sweetened goo filled with stale gumballs.

8. Tom and Jerry- violent and divisive.

9. Richie Rich- terrible role model, absent parents, encouraged mass consumption, promoted money as a solution for problems, the girl character's role was to fawns over him while he solved all of the problems

10. George of the Jungle - mindless show from 1960's- though his Tarzan yell would make a good ringtone.









Lulu KC

(5,147 posts)
20. Hey, who you callin' a dumb broad?
Fri Nov 29, 2024, 01:43 PM
Nov 29

The term is as obsolete and sexist as the mind that created that character.

AZLD4Candidate

(6,411 posts)
21. Except for Richie Rich, none are child cartoon characters. Jerry will be another list I will make, trust me.
Wed Dec 4, 2024, 11:40 PM
Dec 4
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Top Ten worst animated ch...