General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIf Trump wants to send ground troops to Iran:
Why does anyone think Putin won't tip off the Iranians causing our guys get ambushed?
JBTaurus83
(1,375 posts)Provide arms.
David__77
(24,716 posts)They treat Iran as another sovereign state in the global south. Chinas not being interested in playing bloc politics games like the US.
Irish_Dem
(81,213 posts)whathehell
(30,464 posts)Why do we have to assume that?
Intractable
(2,083 posts)Does this really need to be explained?
whathehell
(30,464 posts)24 hours old, and I've had a chance to catch up with the news, it didn't need your sarcastic response either....Bye.
Intractable
(2,083 posts)The answer was obvious 24 hours ago or even two weeks ago.
leftstreet
(40,631 posts)Bluetus
(2,784 posts)Iran has a large military, and they undoubtedly have well-defended positions. I don't see how 3500, 5000, or 17,000 (3 numbers of invasion troops I have heard) can accomplish much of anything unless there are some specific special operation missions.
Just look at the map. They have water on the entire southwest border and that is so heavily armed that the Strait of Hormuz is impassible. Everywhere else, you have borders with nations not particularly friendly to either the US or Israel: Turkey, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Afghanistan. The only bordering countries where the US might be allowed access are Iraq and Pakistan. I can't see a ground assault coming from Pakistan. That's the wrong end of the country.
So what are we going to so, roll in 500 tanks from Iraq. Good luck with that. That would be a killing field. Can anybody think of any sensible ground invasion strategy?
Wednesdays
(22,587 posts)...and I am not a modern military planner, is amphibiously crossing the Strait from the UAE, about 40 miles. And that would have to take a shit ton of naval power, number of tanks and infantry, and air cover that would rival the D-Day invasion.
And from there, it's 700 miles of rugged territory to Tehran.
gab13by13
(32,297 posts)for Iran to attack the air force base that seriously injured 2 Americans and numerous more Americans.
I forget which Arab country the base was located in, Bahrain maybe?
Krasnov is a Russian agent, why wouldn't he give Putin all the details of a ground invasion?
House of Roberts
(6,518 posts)That's where the Shahed supposedly hit the E-3 aircraft mentioned in another OP that also said 12 personnel injured with two seriously injured. The post is at 9:10pm.
Bread and Circuses
(2,033 posts)I hope every soldier, marine, sailor, and airman refuse to fight !
NO American BLOOD for Saudi King/Princes or Israeli war criminals.
JBTaurus83
(1,375 posts)Let them secure their own neighborhood. Both governments are abhorrent. American lives should not be lost for Israel or Saudi Arabia.
Jack Valentino
(4,999 posts)Iran has been preparing for any such instance for TWO DECADES or longer---
The Republican NEO-CONs who gave us the Iraq war, told the whole world
that their "next target" for "regime change" was IRAN !
It didn't happen back then, only because their Iraq regime change operation
ended up with so many US casualties long after we had "won the war",
and because Barack Obama became President for the eight years after Bush Jr...
JBTaurus83
(1,375 posts)Bomb bomb bomb, bomb bomb Iran.
Blue_Roses
(13,879 posts)would have the same thoughts today. For one, he hated Trump. 2)The reason for invading Iran then and now are no longer viable. 3) McCain would not support this chaotic "strategy" and he would be very vocal about it. Just some thoughts...
Jack Valentino
(4,999 posts)he definitely fell victim to their propaganda in that instance....
Jack Valentino
(4,999 posts)good thing he kept his day job.....
Hope22
(4,743 posts)It makes me physically ill to think of the impending debacle. I hope the captains turn around and save the day!
Jack Valentino
(4,999 posts)That was extremely graphic realism, but reportedly a lot of people walked out of their theaters
during the depiction of the Normandy landings because they couldn't take it!.....
(The part I remember most was the soldier who was clearly in shock
who turned back to pick up his own arm, which had been blown off.....)
I suppose if Trump wants "movie quality" scenes, they will be much more 'sanitized',
like the war movies from the 1940s and 50s.....
Hope22
(4,743 posts)In my mind His will be the biggest, bloodiest, most wasteful nightmare. Anything less will be a disappointment to him. Every morning we along with our adversaries wake up to a new threat and eventually real leaders will have their fill of it. Our troops will be sitting ducks but Im pretty sure that they have been started on a course of drugs to make them feel invincible. Tears for the people at home that hope for their return only to have to put the pieces back together. Tears for the lives of our soldiers. I hope this bloody conflict can be avoided. His stain on our country and the lives of our troops becomes bigger by the day.
Fil1957
(705 posts)GoodRaisin
(10,916 posts)He knows if our soldiers start coming home dead his party will be slaughtered in the mid term elections.