Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Dennis Donovan

(28,229 posts)
Sun Jan 5, 2025, 05:37 PM Jan 5

Sherrilyn Ifill: This Is It: Facing Trump 2.0

Sherrilyn Ifill - This Is It: Facing Trump 2.0

Sherrilyn Ifill
Jan 05, 2025



In one of the most important and climatic scenes in the 2006 film Titanic, Rose and her beau Jack are holding on as they stand on tiptoe outside the rails of the upside down ship. As the ship begins its final, rapid descent into the dark, cold waters of the Atlantic, Jack tells Rose, “This is it.” They have received instructions from the ship’s architect on how they might survive once they are in the water. They are both clear about the goals: survive and stay together.

This feels like the moment this country faces as we approach Trump 2.0. In just a few short weeks Donald Trump will return to the White House, bringing with him a coterie of some of the most incompetent and vile miscreants to serve in some of the highest and most consequential civil positions in our government. Their intentions are clear. Their penchant for lies and targeting has already been on display. Their ham-fisted approach to governance is clumsy, cruel, and unethical, but that won’t stop it from being effective. They are prepared to fight battles small and large. With the wind of a conservative Supreme Court and Republican-controlled Congress at their backs, Trump and his team are feeling bold and unstoppable. The outcome seems clear.

But like Rose and Jack, we have goals as well. To survive personally and nationally, with the remnants of democracy still in place so that we have a platform on which to build a new, stronger, healthier democracy. Our other goal is to stay together. We can and must do both.

The greatest obstacle to our fight to survive as a democracy (even a deeply flawed one) and to hold together a semblance of unity among those who believe in the fight for equality and justice in this country, is the inclination to give up – to believe that Trump’s plans cannot be stopped. I agree that they cannot be stopped in total. But I do believe that they can be upended in part, and we must use what powers we have to thwart as many of his harmful policies and plans as we can. It’s also critical for us to play for the future and not just for the present moment. That means it matters that we make a record – a record of Trump’s excesses and lies, but also of police, prosecutor, and judicial misconduct, of corruption - documents and money exchanged, of quid pro quos, and of collaboration with foreign enemies.

Many of us are fighting powerful exhaustion and an ongoing measure of shock that this giant, seemingly unsinkable state-of-the-art democracy (however flawed) can really be about to sink. That exhaustion and disbelief can lead to paralysis, something we can ill afford. I’m reminded that the first thing Jack and Rose did was take deep breaths before holding one long breath as the ship descended. And we must do the same. First pulling in as oxygen those things that nourish us and keep us going. I have encouraged people to lean-in to art, and nature and family and spiritual practice. Establishing a regimen of these things that you will engage and absorb regularly over the next four years is critical. An exercise schedule, morning meditation or prayer, monthly museum visits or concerts, a book club, monthly family dinners, Netflix nights, leaning into your favorite sports team. All of this can help ensure that you are regularly oxygenated throughout what I can guarantee will be moments that will take our breath away in their cruelty and audacity.

/snip
15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Sherrilyn Ifill: This Is It: Facing Trump 2.0 (Original Post) Dennis Donovan Jan 5 OP
Highly recommended. Really good essay. Mike 03 Jan 5 #1
Yes, highly recommended BoRaGard Jan 5 #3
Must read -the whole article malaise Jan 5 #2
Yup, we're at the point of no return now. Initech Jan 5 #4
She is one of... 2naSalit Jan 5 #5
She is a cousin soldierant Jan 5 #7
Love her malaise Jan 5 #10
Yeah, but the Titanic was not actively trying to drag Jack and Rose down with it. OldBaldy1701E Jan 5 #6
I'm also worried about your police and FBI who are so heavily arthritisR_US Jan 6 #15
I don't know if that floating box kairos12 Jan 5 #8
Great essay! Kick bronxiteforever Jan 5 #9
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! Hugin Jan 5 #11
Spoiler alert: ONE of them does not survive. FailureToCommunicate Jan 5 #12
Great Mythbusters Episode... djacq Jan 5 #13
"...the 2006 film Titanic..." 🤨 Blue_Tires Jan 6 #14

Mike 03

(17,764 posts)
1. Highly recommended. Really good essay.
Sun Jan 5, 2025, 05:47 PM
Jan 5

This is also from it:

Generosity and encouragement will be key. Our hands may come apart from time to time, but we can still stay close. Fight those who are opposed to democracy, equality and justice. Not those who are your allies. You can disagree with your allies. Correct them, edify them, firmly push back against them when necessary. But try to reserve your fight for your opponents.


I just subscribed to this substack.

OldBaldy1701E

(6,883 posts)
6. Yeah, but the Titanic was not actively trying to drag Jack and Rose down with it.
Sun Jan 5, 2025, 07:37 PM
Jan 5

Nor was it plotting to destroy Jack and Rose, either. Significant differences.

But, the concept is a good one, even if the author misses something important.

Also, the greatest obstacle to our fight for survival and democracy is the inclination to fight for the existing democracy. In my opinion, the existing system is too flawed and too corrupted to be worth saving. Time to do some serious tweaking. Of course, the current power base would change. And, none of them want that to happen, regardless of their political affiliation. So, what do we do?

To use a house building metaphor: We don't need to tear the whole thing down, but we do need to take it to the foundation. Maybe even the footer.

arthritisR_US

(7,708 posts)
15. I'm also worried about your police and FBI who are so heavily
Mon Jan 6, 2025, 02:10 AM
Jan 6

invested/ inspired by the RW mentality. This orange asshole would put them into the Hoover mentality 😡

djacq

(1,689 posts)
13. Great Mythbusters Episode...
Sun Jan 5, 2025, 08:54 PM
Jan 5


Question:

Is America smart enough to tie a Life jacket under itself?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Sherrilyn Ifill: This Is ...